John Chacko

THE FEED

Mike woke up at 6:14 in the morning, two minutes before his alarm.

He reached for his phone the way most people do now, before his feet touched the floor, before he said a word to his wife, before he even fully decided to be awake. Forty seconds into the morning, he was already angry. Something about a politician. Something about a policy. Something about people on the other side, the ones who just didn’t get it, the ones ruining everything.

By the time he got downstairs and poured his coffee, Mike had already formed three opinions, confirmed two fears, and silently decided that roughly half the country had lost its mind.

He had not looked out the window yet.

He had not spoken to a single human being.

But he was absolutely certain about what was happening in the world.


Here is the strange thing about Mike.

He is not stupid. He is not weak. He is not uniquely gullible or unusually angry. Mike is an engineer. He reads. He votes. He coaches his daughter’s soccer team on Saturdays and he stops to help strangers with flat tires.

Mike is, by every reasonable measure, a good and thoughtful person.

And Mike is being played. Quietly, expertly, around the clock. Without his permission and almost entirely without his knowledge.

The question worth sitting with is not whether Mike is smart enough to see it.

The question is why he hasn’t looked.


Let’s go back to the phone.

Not to the content on it. To the phone itself, the way it works, the thing running underneath every app and feed and notification. There are engineers, very well paid ones, whose entire job is to figure out what makes Mike stop scrolling. Not what informs him. Not what helps him. What stops his thumb.

And after years of research and billions of data points, they found the answer.

It was not beauty. It was not truth. It was not even humor, though humor came close.

It was the thing that made his jaw tighten.

Outrage held attention longer than anything else they tested. Fear kept people on the platform. The feeling that the other side was not just wrong but dangerous, that something needed to be done, that everyone needed to see this, that was the content that traveled. That was the content that got shared. That was the content that made the numbers go up.

So the machine learned to find it. To prioritize it. To put it at the top of Mike’s feed every single morning before his coffee finished brewing.

Nobody called Mike to tell him this was happening. It wasn’t in the terms of service he didn’t read. It just became the water he swam in, and like every creature that lives in water, he stopped noticing it was wet.


Now here is where it gets interesting.

Because this did not start with smartphones. It did not start with Facebook or cable news or even the printing press. The idea at the center of it, keep people divided and they will never unify against the people dividing them, is as old as recorded civilization.

Every empire that ever held power over large numbers of people figured this out eventually. You do not need chains if you can convince the prisoners that the person in the next cell is the real problem. The Roman governors knew it. The colonial administrators knew it. Every political strategist who ever drew a district line or wrote a wedge issue knows it.

What changed is the scale. What changed is the speed. What changed is that the tool is now in everyone’s pocket and it runs itself.

The oldest trick in the world just got a software update.


And here is the part that takes a minute to sit with.

Some of the people who could stop this have quietly decided they would rather not.

Not all of them. But enough. Because the same machine that divides Mike also sorts him. It puts him in a box with everyone who thinks like him, fears like him, votes like him. And once he is in that box, he is very easy to talk to. You know exactly what he needs to hear. You know which word will make him lean in and which image will make him share. You know his box and you have the key to it.

A population sorted into neat, frightened, angry tribes is not a problem for certain kinds of leadership.

It is a resource.

This is not a conspiracy theory. It does not require anyone sitting in a dark room plotting. It only requires people in power noticing what is useful to them and choosing not to disrupt it. That is a much smaller and more human thing. And it has happened in every society in every age, because power has always understood that a people who see themselves as one people are considerably harder to manage than a people who see themselves as enemies of each other.

There is a word for this kind of power. It is not strength. It is closer to shepherding. The flock moves where it is guided and grazes on what it is given and never asks where the fence came from.


So where does that leave Mike?

Scrolling. Certain. Angry before breakfast.

And across town, or across the street, there is a woman named Carol who woke up at the same time, reached for the same kind of phone, and is just as angry, just as certain, and just as convinced that Mike and people like him are the reason everything is falling apart.

Mike and Carol will probably never have a real conversation. The machine does not create those. But they will both see plenty of content about each other, none of it designed to build understanding, all of it designed to make the other seem not just wrong but contemptible.

Neither of them chose this. Neither of them knows it is happening at quite this level.

And neither of them is going to find out from their feed.


Here is a small experiment worth trying.

Find a news story you feel strongly about. Not mildly interesting. The kind that made you want to tell someone. Now trace it backward. Find the original source. Not the article that summarized the article that quoted the press release. The actual source. The study, the document, the statement in full context.

Then ask one more question. Who paid for this? Who funded the research, the report, the organization that released the finding? Not because every funded study is corrupt, but because money has a direction, and knowing the direction tells you something the headline never will.

Most people never do this. Not because they cannot. Because it takes time and the answer might complicate something they already believe, and complication is uncomfortable, and the feed is always right there offering something simpler.

The truth, it turns out, does not come delivered to your door. It does not arrive warm and ready. It is in the back, behind the counter, in the kitchen that most people never enter because they were told the menu was sufficient.

The menu is not sufficient.

The menu is the trick.


There is a thread running through every wisdom tradition that has survived long enough to be worth reading. It shows up in ancient texts, in letters written from prison cells, in the words of people who had every reason to despair and somehow didn’t.

The thread is this: the most dangerous place to live is inside an unexamined story.

Not an evil story, necessarily. Just an unexamined one. One you received rather than built. One that came to you pre-shaped, pre-concluded, with all the messy contradicting details already removed, handed to you at the exact moment you were tired or afraid or looking for something to confirm that you were right.

Every generation in history has faced a version of this. The packaging changes. Pamphlets become newspapers become television become feeds. The vehicle is always new. The vulnerability it targets is always the same.

We were told, a very long time ago, to be careful about what we let in through the gate of our attention. That what we feed grows. That what we do not question eventually becomes the ground we stand on, and that ground can be moved by someone else without us ever feeling it shift.


So what does Mike do tomorrow morning?

Maybe nothing dramatic. Maybe he just pauses, for ten seconds before he opens the phone, and asks himself a single question.

Who benefits from me believing this before I have thought about it?

That question, asked honestly and regularly, is not a political act. It is not an act of cynicism. It is the oldest form of self-respect there is. It is the decision to be a person who thinks rather than a profile that reacts.

Mike is not the problem.

Mike, fully awake, asking real questions, looking at Carol across the street and seeing a person rather than an avatar, is actually the solution.

The machine knows this.

It is why the notification arrives before he is fully conscious.

It is why the alarm is always set for two minutes too late.


Lift your face.

Look around.

The world you were shown this morning is not the only one.

The real one is just outside the window, waiting, the way it always has been, for someone willing to look at it directly.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top